This
month we are excited to bring to you an interview with Terri
Warren, nurse practitioner. Terri is one of the leaders in
Herpes research and treatment in the world. Her research papers
abound in the medical literature in some of the most renowned
and respected journals. Over the past 17 years, Terri has
served as an investigator or sub-investigator on over 70 medical
research studies, and speaks both nationally and internationally
on the subject of genital herpes. A nurse practitioner, she
is the owner of the Westover Heights Clinic in Portland, Oregon.
Established in 1982, the clinic specializes in the diagnosis
and treatment of sexually transmitted diseases. She has been
a member of the executive committee of the American Sexually
Transmitted Disease Association. She is the medical responder
for the herpes website on WebMD. Terri is a member of the
"Stop the Spread" committee of the American Social
Health Association, devoted to herpes prevention. She also
serves as the medical advisor for the local Portland HELP
group.
In addition to Terri's busy life as one of the foremost researchers and practitioners
in the field, she is a single mother of three daughters, one of whom is also
a nurse practitioner. We are so proud to have Terri as a member of our Medical
Advisory Board, and we caught up with her at work on a busy day in Portland.
Dr. H. - Terri, thanks for taking a few minutes to answer some questions
on the "cutting edge" of the state of herpes research as well as to
offer advice to persons suffering with herpes infections.
One question that I get regularly is this: What percentage of relationships
involving herpes infections are "discordant" according to the patient
population that you see, where one member of the relationship has genital herpes
and one does not?
Terri - I estimate that, of the patients in relationships that I see,
approximately a third of those relationships are "discordant", where
one of the members of a couple has a type of genital herpes virus that the other
does not. We always test both members of the couple, by the way, and we believe
that all screens for sexually transmitted diseases should include HSV serology
for both types of herpes simplex virus.
Dr. H. - You participated in some of the early research that indicated
that when infected persons take antiviral medication such as Valtrex, the shedding
of virus by the infected person is dramatically reduced, by as much as 80% or
more. Recently, you've been actively involved in the multi-center study looking
at the protective effect that the taking of Valtrex by the infected partner
has for the uninfected partner in a discordant relationship. The results are
to be announced soon. What can you tell us at this point?
Terri - While I can't talk directly about the study until the results
are announced, I can say that the statement
of the Medical Advisory Board of Herpes.org appears to be correct, though
the final data has not been analyzed. For years, I have been routinely telling
the infected partner of a discordant relationship to take suppressive antiviral
medication to help protect the uninfected partner, even though we do not have
specific data about transmission but because it has demonstrated such a huge
reduction in viral shedding for the infected partner. The results of the transmission
study will be presented in September.
Dr. H. - So, you think that the results of the research will be happy
ones for members of discordant couples?
Terri - I think that the results should be encouraging, yes.
Dr. H. - Well, we will certainly be looking forward to the results of
the study to come out soon. On another note, I came across a study recently
suggesting that taking antiviral medication for a prolonged period at the time
of first diagnosis may be beneficial for the infected person, possibly reducing
the severity of outbreaks later. Any thoughts on this?
Terri - No, there is no evidence that I am aware of that taking antiviral
therapy for a prolonged period when first contracting herpes does anything to
reduce the severity of herpes later on. I think you are referring to the Field
mouse model study, and there is yet to be data to prove that it makes an impact
in humans. However, I believe strongly in starting suppressive (daily) antiviral
therapy at first episode for several other reasons. First, it reduces the number
of outbreaks a person will have in the first year. Outbreaks are more common
in that first year as the body mounts an immune response. Second, it reduces
viral shedding, which is more common in that first year. And third, we believe
it helps people have a "break" from outbreaks that allows them a chance
to adjust psychologically. Currently, we are conducting a study to see if that
last hypothesis is actually true or not.
Dr. H. - One thing that I had been concerned about in the past was in
the setting of relationships where both members have genital herpes. Is it possible
that one partner might infect the other partner in other locations of the body?
What about if the partners have different types of herpes (one with genital
type 1 and one with genital type 2)?
Terri - The current thought is that the whole sacral nerve ganglion
plexus gets infected, though only certain skin areas may break out. So, if both
partners have the same genital type, i.e. both have genital type 1 or both have
genital type 2, we advise them that they do not need to use protection. All
genital infections are "bilateral" almost from the beginning, or certainly
become bilateral soon, with the infection going "up and across" to
the other nerve ganglia, producing a "boxer shorts" distribution of
the nerve ganglia that are actually infected. Steve Sacks, M.D. addresses this
in his book, "The Truth about Herpes".
If one partner has genital type 2 and one partner has genital type 1, then
the person with type 2 doesn't need to worry about getting genital type 1 because
the antibody to type 2 appears to be very protective against getting a new type.
Indeed, the person with genital type 2 is almost non-susceptible to acquiring
genital type 1. The person with genital type 1 should want to avoid acquiring
genital type 2, however, because it can break out more frequently than the genital
type 1 infection. So, precautions should be taken and it is very important that
both partners in a sexual relationship know the type of their genital infection
(1 vs. 2).
Certainly one should avoid transmitting any of the herpes infections to the
face near the eyes, as it is possible to acquire the infection on the cornea.
However, autoinoculation (infecting another part of the body from the main site
of infection) occurs almost exclusively during first episode disease when an
immune response has not yet been fully established.
Dr. H. - Terri, what's the current status of vaccines for herpes infections?
Terri - A large-scale trial is going to begin this summer specifically
on a vaccine that appears to offer some protective benefit for women who are
not infected with either type of herpes simplex virus (type 1 or type 2). The
project is sponsored by the National Institutes of Health and will enroll 7000
women for the study. Previous work indicated that this vaccine could prevent
the acquisition of the virus in 45% of women who had no previous herpes simplex
infection. It appeared to prevent the acquisition of disease in 75% of women,
though.
Dr. H. - Does this mean that someone actually might become infected
but, under the influence of the vaccine, might not develop disease symptoms?
Terri - Apparently, yes.
Dr. H. - You know, a high percentage of people who develop herpes simplex
infections seem not to develop significant, if any symptoms. So, apparently
the immune systems of many people are able to "control" the infection,
for the sake of another term. Does this mean that this vaccine MAY be able to
help induce the immune systems of uninfected women to be able to "control"
the infection in most cases if they get infected, without developing symptoms?
Terri - Possibly. It's still too early to know the actual mechanism
of controlling infections through stimulating the immune system. It is also
true that although many people don't report having symptoms, they really do
have symptoms but don't recognize them until someone teaches them about all
the possible ways that genital herpes can present itself. Once people are taught
about that, about 50% of those unable to recognize symptoms previously can then
do so.
Dr. H. - Speaking of stimulating the immune system, a good bit of research
is being done now on a family of drugs called "immune modulators".
One is already on the market, called imiquimod, brand name "Aldara",
currently approved by the FDA for the treatment of genital warts. Another member
of the family, resiquimod, is in testing now. The literature seems to suggest
that the frequency of outbreaks is reduced, sometimes pretty dramatically, by
the use of these topical chemicals. Any thoughts?
Terri - The preliminary results (presented by Dr. Steve Tyring in the
Journal of Infectious Diseases) seem very positive as far as reducing frequency
of outbreaks. However, even with the use of the chemical, recurrent outbreaks,
when they occur, do not appear to be any shorter. And, the chemical can be quite
irritating to the skin, sometimes producing skin ulcers in the area that it
is used. So, it remains to be seen what the role of these immune system modifiers
will be.
Dr. H. - I have read about a whole new class of antiviral chemicals
called "helicase inhibitors" for herpes simplex infections. Any comments?
Terri - Drug companies appear to be reluctant to jump on this new drug
family for treatment of herpes infections. They appear reluctant to develop
them at this point, not being sure if they will be able to recoup their investment
in the drugs. These drugs are not in human trials at this time, but perhaps
in the future. We sure hope so!
Dr. H. - Last question: How can people get easily tested for herpes
infections?
Terri - I recommend that people interested in getting tested go to www.healthcheckUSA.com
. They can get their own serology for herpes by locating a facility in their
area through the website that does the HerpesSelect IgG antibody blood tests.
However, they also offer the IgM test for HSV 1 and 2, and that one should be
avoided because it is not truly type specific and may not accurately define
a true first episode infection. I refer lots of people there who request testing
information at my WebMD herpes message board. There are still the old bad tests
on the market, and sometimes people's health care providers just don't know
which test their lab uses. At least this way, I know they are getting the new
HerpeSelect test and that their results will be very accurate, assuming people
wait 3 months from possible exposure to testing.
Dr. H. - Terri, thanks so much for taking the time for this dialogue,
and thank you for everything you do for helping those dealing with these issues.
Terri - My pleasure! Take care!
Please let me know if this sort of format
is the type of newsletter that you would like to see.
If you have any feedback, please click here!
|